9 mins read

Accounts Payable Fraud

The Importance of Segregation of Duties in Accounts Payable

by Yooz the 07.6.2023

segregation of duties accounts payable

Protecting your company's finances and preserving its reputation are crucial aspects of achieving business success. However, the increasing threat of Accounts Payable fraud poses a significant risk, one that can potentially result in substantial financial losses and reputational damage. To mitigate this risk – either external or via employee fraud - implementing strong Accounts Payable controls becomes essential.

Let's examine further the importance of internal controls and delve specifically into the powerful role that segregating duties with Accounts Payable plays as a deterrent against internal or external fraud. By adopting these measures, you can safeguard the integrity of your financial operations and strengthen your organisation against potential threats.


CTA-UK-Whitepaper-Not Mess AP project


Enhancing accountability and accuracy using internal controls in Accounts Payable


According to the Financial Reporting Standards (FRS) issued by the Financial Reporting Council (FRC), utilizing strong internal controls is crucial to prevent fraud and errors, ensuring the accuracy and reliability of financial reports and statements. Effectively implementing these controls is essential for upholding the integrity of an organisation's accounting operations.


Segregation of duties: a key internal control


One of the most vital internal controls within an Accounts Payable department is Segregation of Duties (SOD), where key responsibilities are divided among multiple individuals. It is crucial to assign different individuals to different aspects of the process, such as invoice approval, transaction recording, and payment issuance.


Approvals: strengthening control


In addition to segregation of duties in the Accounts Payable process, several other internal controls can also be implemented. For example, all invoices should be thoroughly reviewed and approved by someone other than the person responsible for initiating the transaction. This practice effectively prevents fraudulent activities like payment fraud, where payments are made to fictitious vendors or duplicate payments are issued.


Purchase orders: ensuring authorization


The use of purchase orders is another important internal control. These documents outline the specific goods or services to be procured, their corresponding prices, the purchase order process, and the transaction terms. By mandating the use of purchase orders for all transactions, organisations can ensure that only authorised purchases are made.


Additional internal controls: strengthening oversight


There are several other internal controls that can also be implemented, including periodic audits of vendor records, the adoption of pre-numbered checks, and the use of electronic payments. These measures provide an additional layer of oversight and accountability in the payment process, ensuring the accuracy and reliability of financial reporting.


Regular evaluation and adoption


It is important to emphasise that all these internal and external controls should undergo regular reviews and updates to maintain their effectiveness and minimise any risk exposure. As new risks emerge, organisations must adapt their internal controls accordingly to prevent fraud and errors.

In conclusion, the use of internal controls is indispensable in the Accounts Payable function to mitigate fraud, reduce errors, and ensure data accuracy. While segregation of duties remains a critical control, there are several others that can be implemented to strengthen the overall control environment. 

Simply put, by consistently reviewing and updating internal controls, organisations can proactively address emerging business risks, minimise human error, and maintain a high level of integrity in their accounting processes.




Segregation of duties in Accounts Payable


As stated above, segregation of duties plays a vital role in ensuring effective internal controls within the Accounts Payable department. Let's explore this concept further and explore why dividing responsibilities is of utmost importance to safeguard against fraud and errors.

At its core, the segregation of duties control mechanism necessitates the involvement of multiple individuals in completing tasks or a series of tasks. Specifically in the case of Accounts Payable, this means that no single person is granted complete authority over any specific aspect of the Accounts Payable process. Instead, distinct responsibilities are assigned to various individuals, establishing a system of checks and balances.

For instance, one person may be responsible for invoice approval, another for recording transactions, and a third individual for overseeing payment issuance. By dividing these responsibilities among multiple individuals, no one person has absolute control over the entire payment process. This ensures that the system operates with checks and balances in place, significantly reducing the risk of fraud or errors.

The idea behind segregating duties lies in the fact that involving multiple individuals makes it significantly harder for any individual to commit fraud without detection. For example, if one person is solely responsible for approving invoices and another person responsible for issuing payments, they could potentially create false invoices and approve them for payment, leading to fraudulent disbursements. However, by separating these responsibilities, it becomes notably harder for a fraudster to carry out such a scheme without raising suspicion.

It is crucial to emphasise that segregation of duties in Accounts Payable serves as a strong deterrent against fraud and errors by ensuring that no individual has the ability to manipulate the system for personal gain. This aspect holds particular significance in light of the increasing risk of fraud in the Accounts Payable process, as studies reveal that Accounts Payable fraud is one of the most prevalent types of misconduct committed by employees. 




Which duties should be segregated?


Determining the duties that should be segregated is crucial for establishing effective checks and balances. Here are some examples of key duties that should be overseen by multiple individuals:


  • Purchase orders: The creation and approval of purchase orders should involve different individuals to prevent unauthorized or fraudulent orders.
  • Invoice processing: Invoice verification and processing should be handled by multiple people to ensure accuracy and detect any irregularities or errors.
  • Payment authorisation: Clear approval levels and roles should be defined throughout the entire process. Individuals responsible for payment authorisation should be different from those involved in other purchasing or processing steps to minimise the risk of improper payments.
  • Bank reconciliations: It is important to have multiple individuals involved in the bank reconciliation process. These individuals should not be engaged in any other part of the transaction process to avoid conflicts of interest and enhance the accuracy of reconciliations.

It's important to note that the specific duties requiring segregation may vary based on the organisation's size and internal control requirements. While complete separation is ideal, practical limitations may exist.


How to implement accounts payable segregation of duties


Here are five steps for organizations to follow when implementing segregation of duties in Accounts Payable:


Step 1: Analyze the current process


Identify the tasks and responsibilities involved in the Accounts Payable process including invoice processing, data entry, payment approvals, vendor setup, and reconciliation.


Step 2: Assign key roles and responsibilities


Once you have identified the key roles, assign them to different individuals or teams to ensure that no individual has too much control over multiple critical tasks that could lead to a conflict of interest. Create a segregation of duties matrix that clearly matches roles to responsibilities.


Step 3: Define clear authorization levels


Establish transparent authorization levels and limits for each role involved in the process to ensure accountability and prevent unauthorized actions by either individual or multiple employees.


Step 4: Document policies and procedures


Develop comprehensive policies and procedures that outline the segregation of duties controls in the Accounts Payable process. Clearly define the roles and responsibilities involved, as well as the steps required for invoice payment processing, payment approvals, and vendor management.


Step 5: Regularly review and monitor compliance


Conduct regular reviews and audits to ensure compliance with the segregation of duties controls. Make necessary adjustments to address any identified weaknesses or gaps in the process.


It’s important to remember that segregation of duties is just one part of an overall internal control framework. It's important to involve relevant stakeholders and ensure that they understand their responsibilities in order to effectively implement and maintain these controls.

By implementing these policies and procedures, organisations can establish a system of checks and balances, mitigating the risk of fraud and ensuring the accuracy of accuracy of financial reporting.




The benefits of segregation of duties in Accounts Payable internal controls


Implementing segregation of duties in Accounts Payable provides numerous benefits, including:


  • Fraud prevention and error detection


By dividing responsibilities, segregation of duties establishes a system of checks and balances that deters fraud and facilitates the early detection of errors.


When multiple individuals are involved in pay controls, it becomes significantly more challenging for any one person to engage in fraudulent activities or make errors without being detected. This helps safeguard the organisation's assets and ensures the accuracy of financial statements and transactions.


  • Enhanced accuracy and reliability of financial reporting


Segregation of duties in Accounts Payable improves the accuracy and reliability of financial reporting.


When different individuals are responsible for approving invoices, recording transactions, and issuing payments, it reduces the risk of errors and inaccuracies occurring inthe accounting records. By maintaining accurate financial data, organisations can make informed decisions and comply with regulatory requirements.


  • Increased transparency and accountability


Segregation of Accounts Payable duties promotes transparency and accountability within the Accounts Payable process.


When multiple individuals are involved in the process, it becomes easier to trace the flow of financial transactions and identify any irregularities. This transparency enhances internal controls, facilitates effective audits, and ensures accountability for actions taken throughout the payment process.


  • Streamlined efficiency in Accounts Payable


Assigning specific roles to different individuals as part of segregation of duties enhances the overall efficiency of the Accounts Payable process.


Each person has a clearly defined responsibility, reducing the likelihood of bottlenecks and delays processing payments. With streamlined payment processes, organisations can improve cash flow management, optimise vendor relationships, and achieve timely payments, all of which contribute to operating efficiently.


What does it all mean?

In summation, segregation of duties in Accounts Payable provides significant benefits that include fraud prevention, error detection, improved financial reporting accuracy, increased transparency and accountability, and streamlined process efficiency. By implementing these controls, organisations can enhance their financial integrity, protect their assets, and maintain trust with stakeholders.


Enhancing internal controls through Accounts Payable automation software


Embracing automation and accounting software is now a critical strategic imperative for organisations. By leveraging technology, businesses can optimise their internal controls, streamline processes, and mitigate risk.

Automation not only minimises the potential for human error but provides real-time visibility into operations, empowering proactive decision-making. With the right tools and systems in place, companies can strengthen internal controls, enhance efficiency, and ensure compliance with regulatory requirements. By embracing automation, organisations can unlock substantial benefits and gain a competitive edge in today’s dynamic business environment.

To learn more about how Yooz can help you move forward in today's digital landscape, schedule a free demo today.

CTA-UK  Private Demo